Skip to content
Evergreen Crates logo

Crates or cardboard

Plastic moving crates vs cardboard boxes

Cardboard has to be bought, built, taped, carried without handles, kept out of the rain, flattened and got rid of. Crates turn up ready to fill and we take them away. Same price or less, all in.

Are plastic crates better than cardboard boxes for moving?

Crates, and it is not close. Cardboard has to be bought, built, taped, carried with no handles, kept out of the rain, flattened and got rid of. Crates turn up at your door ready to fill, clip shut, stack without crushing, wheel out on a dolly, and we take them away afterwards. All in, they cost the same as cardboard or less.

With crates you never

  • Hunt for boxes, or go back for more at nine at night
  • Fold and tape a house full of boxes
  • Cut boxes open to find the kettle, then tape them up again
  • Catch a box as the bottom gives way
  • Carry a box with no handles and no view of your feet
  • Watch a damp box go soft on the drive
  • Flatten a mountain of cardboard in your new hallway
  • Wait weeks for the bin to take it, or drive it to the tip

How do crates and cardboard compare, step by step?

Here is one move, from getting the boxes to getting rid of them, done with cardboard and done with our crates.

  1. Getting the boxes

    With cardboard

    A box kit ordered online and a wait to see if it turns up before moving day. Then you find, like everybody does, that you need far more than you thought, and you are ordering again halfway through the kitchen.

    With our crates

    They arrive at your door on the day you choose, the right number for your home, with a dolly.

  2. Getting them ready

    With cardboard

    Every single box folded into shape and taped across the bottom, twice if you want it to hold. A home's worth of them, with a tape gun that jams, a roll you cannot find the end of, and cheap tape that splits or will not stick.

    With our crates

    Nothing to build. Take a crate off the stack and start filling it.

  3. Closing them

    With cardboard

    Tape the top shut. Then cut it open again because the kettle, the phone charger or the passports are in there somewhere, and tape it up again.

    With our crates

    The lid clips shut in a second and opens just as fast. No tape, ever.

  4. Heavy things

    With cardboard

    Books, crockery and tins make the bottom bow, and the cut-out handles tear. Pick it up wrong and the base splits, and everything you packed is on the floor.

    With our crates

    Rigid 65-litre crates with a solid base that hold 35kg and more. Books and crockery stay in. Pack heavy things to about 25kg a crate and they stay easy to lift.

  5. Carrying

    With cardboard

    No proper handles, so it is arms round the box, hands underneath and chin on top, and you cannot see your feet on the stairs. HSE's lifting guidance prefers loads with handles that give a strong grip, and flags loads too big to see over.

    With our crates

    Hand grips on each crate, and a dolly with every hire, so a whole stack wheels out to the van in one go.

  6. Rain on moving day

    With cardboard

    Cardboard soaks up rain. A damp box goes soft and can give way between the front door and the van.

    With our crates

    Plastic does not go soft in the wet, so a shower on the drive does not turn into a split box.

  7. Stacking in the van or a storage unit

    With cardboard

    Odd sizes that will not stack square, half-full boxes that fold when something goes on top, and the heaviest boxes at the bottom, which is exactly where cardboard buckles and crushes.

    With our crates

    The crates are made to stack, so a full stack stands square and the weight sits on the crate walls, not on your things.

  8. Finding things at the other end

    With cardboard

    A room full of identical brown boxes and a scribbled word on each one, if you remembered.

    With our crates

    Free labels that peel off cleanly. Write the room on the crate and it goes straight to the right room.

  9. After you unpack

    With cardboard

    Weeks of living in a maze of boxes, then every one cut open, the tape ripped off and the box flattened. The recycling bin is full after the first few, most councils here only empty it every two to four weeks, and the tip needs a booked slot.

    With our crates

    The empties nest inside each other and sit in a corner until we collect them. Nothing to flatten, nothing to bin, nothing to drive anywhere. Leave any used packing paper in a crate and we take that too.

  10. What it costs

    With cardboard

    The boxes are only the start. Then the tape, the tape gun, marker pens, a trolley, delivery on a box kit, and the fuel for every trip to buy them and get rid of them.

    With our crates

    One price from £79, with the crates, a dolly, labels, delivery and collection included and no VAT to add. All in, it works out the same as cardboard or less.

What goes wrong with cardboard boxes on moving day?

The bottoms go first. A box of books or plates sags, the tape lets go, and everything lands on the floor, usually on the stairs. Then the rain softens anything left on the drive, the heavy boxes at the bottom of the van crush under the ones above, and every box you lift has no handles, so you carry it hugged to your chest without seeing your feet.

And that is the day itself. Before it come the evenings of folding and taping, with the tape gun that jams and the roll you cannot find the end of. After it comes a hallway full of flattened boxes, a recycling bin that is full after the first few, and a trip to the tip.

A crate has none of these problems. Rigid 65-litre crates hold 35kg and more, the lid clips shut, the hand grips mean you can see where you are going, and a dolly takes the whole stack to the van.

Book your crates

Are plastic crates or cardboard boxes cheaper?

All in, crates work out the same or cheaper. Our Studio package is £79 for 20 crates for two weeks, and that one price covers delivery to your door, collection afterwards, a dolly and labels. With cardboard the boxes are only the start: then come tape, a tape gun, marker pens, a trolley, the trip to buy it all and the trip to get rid of it.

Can't I just get free cardboard boxes?

You can, and they cost you in other ways. Free boxes come in every shape, so they will not stack in the van. They have already done one trip and they are weaker for it, and you do not know where they have been. You still need the tape, the trolley and the evenings building them, and you still have to get rid of them afterwards.

See every package on our crate hire prices page, or read how reusable moving box hire works.

Why do people choose crates over cardboard boxes?

Because every job cardboard makes you do, the crates either do for you or do away with.

  • Delivered to your door

    On the day you choose. No shop trips and no waiting in for a box kit.

  • Ready to fill straight away

    Nothing to fold or build. Take a crate off the stack and pack.

  • No tape at all

    The lid clips shut. No tape gun, no tape, no cutting boxes open to find the kettle.

  • 65 litres, holds 35kg and more

    A good size that takes plenty. Rigid sides and a solid base keep books and crockery in; pack to about 25kg so it stays easy to lift.

  • Hand grips on every crate

    Carry it properly, with your arms free of the bottom and your feet in sight.

  • A dolly with every hire

    Wheel a stack of full crates to the van in one trip instead of ten.

  • Stacks square and safe

    Made to stack, so they stand firm in the van or a storage unit without crushing.

  • Does not go soft in the rain

    Plastic shrugs off a wet drive that would turn a cardboard box to mush.

  • Lids keep the dust off

    Clip the lid down and the contents stay covered, in the van and in storage.

  • Free labels

    Write the room on it and peel it off afterwards. Every crate goes to the right room.

  • Seals for valuables

    Numbered tamper-evident seals, £8.50 a pack of 20, show at a glance if a crate has been opened.

  • Time to pack properly

    Two weeks as standard, four if you want them, and extend by the day if the move slips.

  • Clean every time

    Every crate is sanitised before it goes out to you.

  • Empties nest away

    Once unpacked, the crates nest inside each other and take up a corner, not your whole hallway.

  • Collected when you are done

    We take the empties away. No flattening, no full bin, no trip to the tip.

  • One price, nothing to add

    From £79, with delivery, collection, a dolly and labels included. No VAT.

  • Top up any time

    Need a few more? Extra crates are £3 each when you book.

  • Used again and again

    The same crates go from move to move, so nothing is made for your move and nothing is thrown away after it.

Are reusable crates greener than cardboard?

Yes, because they are used again and again. Each crate goes from hire to hire: we collect it, sanitise it and send it out again, so no boxes are made for your move and none are thrown away after it.

Are reusable moving boxes greener? The full answer

Six green plastic crates stacked in two columns beside a red sack truck, with one lid standing open

Are crates better than cardboard for storage?

Yes. Crates hold their shape in a tall stack, so you can use the full height of a unit and nothing at the bottom gets crushed, and the lids keep the dust off for as long as they are there. On a storage move, crates cost £1 each a month, or £12 each to buy.

You pack the crates and we carry them into your unit on a crated storage move.

What do people worry about when they hire crates?

Three things, and none of them applies here. Dirty crates: every one is cleaned and sanitised before it reaches you. Surprise delivery charges: delivery and collection are in the price, anywhere within 30 miles of Sudbury. Charges for crates: you only pay £10 for a crate that does not come back or is damaged beyond normal wear.

Ready to move without the cardboard?

Crates, a dolly, labels, delivery and collection, from £79.